Marvel Chronology Project

I don't have the book in front of me; I'm only addressing the policies/philosophies raised in your post. Even if the whole story was only a dream ..., we can consider that his dreamself is an appearance of the character. From the FAQ : 3. Was this really an appearance, as opposed to a dream sequence...

As a matter of fact, I was. And no one would have to convince me that we could make mistakes of omission. :shrug: We're human. I was also one of the writers of the Thor Index, and after it was published, Chrissy was reading an issue of Journey Into Mystery, and said, "That sure looks like Thund...

The Official Index to the Fantastic Four #1 (1985) states that FF 9 is that particular cyclops' first and only appearance. Marvel Saga #8 (1986) describes the FF character as "a gigantic creature mutated to resemble the one-eyed cyclops from the days of the Greek myths". And, as already n...

We...may be talking about two different things, but let's get back on track. Based on information in Official Index of the Fantastic Four #1, Marvel Saga #8 and Punisher: Official Index to the Marvel Universe , the cyclops who appeared in FF 9 is a different character than the one who appeared in th...

zuckyd1 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 13, 2022 9:08 am Unless it was an oversight, wouldn't the omission of specific issues in a chronology count as evidence?

zuckyd1 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 13, 2022 9:08 am Unless it was an oversight

zuckyd1 wrote: ↑Sun Nov 13, 2022 9:08 am oversight...?

You are correct.

Be careful about using lack of evidence as evidence.

SEP220976 BLADE VAMPIRE NATION #1 $4.99 SEP220979 BLADE VAMPIRE NATION #1 INHYUK LEE VAR $4.99 SEP220977 BLADE VAMPIRE NATION #1 LOZANO VAR $4.99 SEP220984 CAPTAIN AMERICA WINTER SOLDIER SPECIAL #1 $4.99 SEP220985 CAPTAIN AMERICA WINTER SOLDIER SPECIAL #1 CARNERO SPOIL VAR $4.99 SEP220986 CAPTAIN AM...

Unless he's also speaking on a phone to the Premier, then no. Simply talking to a picture of a character doesn't warrant a BTS appearance. He may say that he's speaking to the Premier, but that just shows his mental instability. He's talking to himself.

RobinHoodMtl wrote: ↑Thu Nov 10, 2022 4:47 pm
KHRUSHCHEV, NIKITA
[...]
IH 1-BTS --> (add)
[...]

What's the nature of the behind-the-scenes appearance. Unless it's something more than what you've described, it doesn't qualify as BTS.

SEP220947 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #13 $3.99 SEP220949 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #13 MANDRYK BEYOND AMAZING SPIDER-MAN VAR $3.99 SEP220948 AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #13 STEGMAN X-TREME MARVEL VAR $3.99 SEP220857 AVENGERS #62 $3.99 SEP220858 AVENGERS #62 MCKONE X-TREMEME MARVEL VAR $3.99 SEP220886 AXE JUDGMENT DAY OMEGA...

This is my listing for this period, based on Col_Fury's listing, completed with page-numbered FB. A5 34 NA3 16 NA3 17 NA3 20 (1 - 3)-FB NA3 20 (16 - 17)-FB NA3 18 (1 - 10) NA3 21 (1:3 - 2)-FB NA3 18 (11 - 18) NA3 19 (3 - 4)-FB NA3 19 (12:3 - 14)-FB NA3 18 (19 - 20) NA3 19 NA3 20 NA3 21 NA3 22 Here,...

So to illustrate my understanding of your method, let's say that for a given story, three books are telling about the same story, and the series are called A, B and C. And the cutting of all scenes in that story/arc could go something like this: C 10 (1-4) A 1 (1-11) B 7 (1-2:1) C 10 (5-6) B 7 (2:2...

I have to disagree on this one. I understand Russ's rule about contiguous panels and all, but I think it refers to a same scene, doesn't it? But it is not exactly the case here. Allow me to break it down for you: I'll leave it to michel to address the bulk of your post; just popping in here. I woul...

And we've gone over this already. The only flashback in 230 is the inside flashback to Manolis's murder. I got that. But I think the other characters have caught up with the Kingpin's timeline in those pages. Extracting half a page is odd. When modern cartoonists want to set a sequence apart from t...