Marvel Chronology Project

Surely the original state with {ASM 1} was correct because it indicates the 1st published appearance where it isn't the 1st entry in the chronology. If I read Russ Chappell's MCP Stylebook aright.

Ooops! After I wrote the above Leoparis pointed out to me that it's what michel meant.

In Col_Fury's 6/9/2014 SUB-M#38-FB thread he split that issue up more. This is the part of Sub-Mariner's chronology that is relevant to Leoparis, and I've attached [comments] to the SUB-M#38 entries:- M/MYSTERY 2/3 (1:1 - 1:3) *SUB-M 38 (9:4 - 9:5)-FB [N flies to NY] SAGASM 3 (1 - 2)-FB … SAGASM 3 (...

In the live Forum Col_Fury amended Dhall's chronology in 2 posts 12/6/2014 SUB-MARINER COMICS 32 and 6/10/2014 SUB-M 38-FB. In the 1st the relevant part of Namor's chronology is:- SUB-M 38-FB **SUB-MARINER COMICS 32/2 (delete) *SUB-MARINER COMICS 32/3 (1:1 - 1:3) M/COMICS 1/3 (9:1 - 9:2) *SUB-MARINE...

There's something I forgot about which sheds some light on Dhall's intentions for SUB-MARINER COMICS 32/2. His entry for Betty Dean starts **SUB-MARINER COMICS 32/2 (Officer Betty Dean encounters Namor in New York City) **SAGASM 3-FB **MARVEL MYSTERY COMICS 3/3 **SAGASM 3-FB **MARVEL MYSTERY COMICS ...

I've been delving into the history of changes to this part of Sub-Mariner's career, in the Forum and the Archives before it. Dhall made the 1st important contribution in his 24/8/2007 archived Issue Analysis thread Namor: The Early Years. He included everything from his conception to GSINV#1. Judgin...

Victor Von Doom's chronology has P2 29 PWJ 12 PWJ 13 A 313-BTS ASM 513-FB-BTS ASM 502-FB MMACAD 12 MMACAD 13 FF@ 23/2-FB FF@ 23/2 IMPMSUMV 1/7 AF 90 AF 91 XCAL 37 XCAL 38 XCAL 39 FF 350 Kristoff Vernard's chronology has T 410 P2 28 P2 29 FF 350 FF 352 However the Dr Doom in most of AF#90-91 is actua...

I have a question about the position of Iron Man #39. This chronology has IM#39(10-20) & IM#40 between the beginning and A#92-93, which by definition puts it between A#91 (in the previous chronology) and A#92. However Goliath (Clint Barton)'s chronology has IM#39 between A#88 and A#90. For the o...

However there's another variation from the existing chronologies that I still can't find an explanation for. And this 1 worries me more. The following section is highlighted in bold indicating it's all been changed:- Incredible Hulk 109 (1-9) Hulk vs Fin Fang Foom 1 Incredible Hulk 109 (10-20) Incre...

I'll now dig myself out of the hole I've just fallen into. After reading some of the previous comments on this thread I've followed a link back to a Hulk-based discussion on the position of SS#4 where the very change I've been querying has been approved (but presumably not yet implemented in the chr...

Is there any reason why you have Silver Surfer #4 between Avengers #59 and #60 when Thor's chronology has it between Av#52 and #58? I can't see any particular reason to choose 1 over the other. We seem to have altered the relationship between Thor and the Avengers around this area in the Official In...

I've just looked up these 2 issues on GCD which indicates that #17 was mistakenly printed with some wrong pages in CB and the SHIELD reprint. It says that #18 included an insert of the correct colour outer section, with instructions to pull it out and wrap it round the B&W inner pages of #17. I ...

I've checked my original copies of these UK issues, and I have different material in CB 17 (1 - 2) and CB 17 (5 - 6). CB 17 (1 - 2) (with the title The Revenge Of The Red Skull) When they get to Braddock Manor the Caps are attacked by swastika-uniformed goons, and they fight them off. CB 17 (5) Red ...

I forgot that Ebony Maw and Proxima Midnight are affected by moving Gamora's origin. Currently we have:- EBONY MAW ========= THANOS:AGUTL 3-FB THANOS:AGUTL 4-FB THANOS:AGUTL 5-FB THANOS:AGUTL 6-FB THANOS3 1-FB THANOS3 2-FB THANOS3 3-FB THANOS3 4-FB THANOS3 5-FB THANOS3 6-FB {MA2 1} NA3 8 ----- PROXI...

Loki currently has:- JIM 645 YA2 10-FB M/NPO /4 YA2 1 YA2 2 YA2 3 YA2 4 YA2 5 YA2 7-FB YA2 7 YA2 8 YA2 9 YA2 10 YA2 11 YA2 12 YA2 13 YA2 14 YA2 15 APLUSX 5/2 LOKI:AOA 1 (2)-FB LOKI:AOA 1 (16:4)-FB ANM/NPO LOKI:AOA 1 (3 - 15:1)-FB LOKI:AOA 1 JIM#645 is the start of the new conflicted Kid Loki with ol...

In our chronology Hawkeye vol 4 is way after IM#526 where Mandarin dies and #527 where Crimson Cowl dies. So whoever this Crimson Cowl is her app in HAWK4#4 is in the wrong place. It must be after IM#527 not before IIM#25. The question remains who is she? I completely agree that neither Justine Hamm...