Spider-Man/Wolverine mini-series, continuity??
Posted: Wed Jan 14, 2009 9:57 pm
First I just want to say, as a fellow chronology nutball, I've enjoyed this site for a couple years now and just recently I've gotten the courage to join the forums. Thanks for having me. One of the reasons I've joined was because I had a few issues I wanted to address. Nobody has ever questioned the validity of the Marvel Knights Spider-Man/Wolverine mini-series. To me personally, this cannot be in continuity. Here is my argument:
Since Peter is teaching and Aunt May knows he is Spider-Man, this series would have to be placed after Amazing (Vol.2) #35. Yet Peter and Logan act like they have never met. Here are some examples-
1.) When Spidey asks Nick Fury "How'll I recognize the guy", Nick says "He'll stick out". Why doesn't Nick just say "Oh it's just Wolverine" or something like that?
2.) Spidey says "Whoa" when he sees Logan pop his claws and also seems surprised when he sees his healing ability.
3.) Spidey reveals his identity to Logan in issue #2. But in Secret War #2, when Wolvie sees Peter on the plane out of his costume, he says "Never met you out of costume". Also, not once in the first issue do they call each other by their codenames. Actually, I don't think they ever do.
4.) In issue #3, Spidey makes fun of Logan because he wears a costume. That seems really odd.
I've had a problem with this series for awhile now. If anybody can argue against me, please do so.
Keep up the good work guys.
Since Peter is teaching and Aunt May knows he is Spider-Man, this series would have to be placed after Amazing (Vol.2) #35. Yet Peter and Logan act like they have never met. Here are some examples-
1.) When Spidey asks Nick Fury "How'll I recognize the guy", Nick says "He'll stick out". Why doesn't Nick just say "Oh it's just Wolverine" or something like that?
2.) Spidey says "Whoa" when he sees Logan pop his claws and also seems surprised when he sees his healing ability.
3.) Spidey reveals his identity to Logan in issue #2. But in Secret War #2, when Wolvie sees Peter on the plane out of his costume, he says "Never met you out of costume". Also, not once in the first issue do they call each other by their codenames. Actually, I don't think they ever do.
4.) In issue #3, Spidey makes fun of Logan because he wears a costume. That seems really odd.
I've had a problem with this series for awhile now. If anybody can argue against me, please do so.
Keep up the good work guys.