While looking through the latest Index, I found some discrepancies. I checked the individual character chronologies on this web site and found the exact same discrepancies.
According to the current chronologies for Wolverine, Bishop, Storm, Jubilee, Cyclops, and Professor X on this site and in the Marvel Index, X-Men #8 occurs before Uncanny X-Men #288, but the Chronology for Jean Grey shows X-Men #8 occurring after Uncanny X-Men #288. Also, the chronology for Professor X shows Excalibur #52 occurring before Uncanny X-Men #288, but the Chronology for Jean Grey shows Excalibur #52 occurring after Uncanny X-Men #288
Jean Grey (Current Chronology)
UX 287
UX@16
UX 288
X 8
XCAL 51-BTS
XCAL 52
The chronology for Jean Grey should be changed to:
Jean Grey (Suggested Updated Chronology)
UX 287
X 8
UX@16
XCAL 51-BTS
XCAL 52
UX 288
The chronology for Professor X has Wolverine: Evilution occurring before X-Men #8, whereas, the chronology for Wolverine has Wolverine: Evilution occurring after X-Men #8. Also, in Professor X’s chronology, Uncanny X-Men Annual #16 occurs before X-Men #8, but the chronologies for Bishop and Storm show Uncanny X-Men Annual #16 occurring after X-Men #8.
Professor X (Current Chronology)
UX 287
W:EVIL-BTS
UX@16
XF 78
X 8
XCAL 52
UX 288
UX 289
In Professor X’s chronology, place W:EVIL-BTS between UX 288 and UX 289 and place UX@16 between X 8 and XCAL 52:
Professor X (Suggested Updated Chronology)
UX 287
XF 78
X 8
UX@16
XCAL 52
UX 288
W:EVIL-BTS
UX 289
The chronology for Professor X has Hell’s Angel #1-4 occurring before Marvel Comics Presents #117-122, but the chronology for Wolverine has Hell’s Angel #1-5 occurring after Marvel Comics Presents #117-122.
Professor X (Current Chronology)
HA 1
HA 2
HA 3-BTS
HA 4
UX 291
UX 292
UX 293
MCP 17
MCP 18
MCP 19
MCP 20-BTS
MCP 21-BTS
MCP 22-BTS
It can probably go either way, so why not just move Hell’s Angel down in Professor X’s chronology:
Professor X (Suggested Updated Chronology)
UX 291
UX 292
UX 293
MCP 17
MCP 18
MCP 19
MCP 20-BTS
MCP 21-BTS
MCP 22-BTS
HA 1
HA 2
HA 3-BTS
HA 4
Finally (whew!)
The chronologies for Wolverine, Psylocke, and Rogue show X-Men #12-13 occurring before Death’s Head II #1-4, whereas, the chronologies for Cyclops, Beast, and Gambit show X-Men #12-13 occurring after Death’s Head II #1-4.
Wolverine (Current Chronology)
X 12
X 13
WARH 8
WARH 9
C:GENE 1
C:GENE 2
C:GENE 3
C:GENE 4
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
Psylocke (Current Chronology)
X 12
WARH 9
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
Rogue (Current Chronology)
X 12
X 13
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
Cyclops (Current Chronology)
WARH 8
WARH 9
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
X 12
X 13
Beast (Current Chronology)
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
X 12
X 13
Gambit (Current Chronology)
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
X 12
X 13
X-Men #12-13 should be moved in the chronologies for Wolverine, Psylocke, and Rogue and placed after Death’s Head II #1-4 since Psylocke leaves in X-Men #12 to visit her brother in England and cannot be in the mansion to appear in Warheads #9 and the Death’s Head II Limited Series.
Wolverine (Suggested Updated Chronology)
WARH 8
WARH 9
C:GENE 1
C:GENE 2
C:GENE 3
C:GENE 4
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
X 12
X 13
Psylocke (Suggested Updated Chronology)
WARH 9
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
X 12
Rogue (Suggested Updated Chronology)
DHII2 1
DHII2 2
DHII2 3
DHII2 4
X 12
X 13
Official Index to the Marvel Universe #7
Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb
-
- Minion
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sun Nov 02, 2008 8:24 am
- Russ Chappell
- Site Admin
- Posts: 5670
- Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2004 5:40 pm
- Location: Tuscaloosa, AL
- Contact:
Re: Official Index to the Marvel Universe #7
Do you have these books?
I can't promise you that things will improve, if we make changes;
I can promise you that they won't improve, if we don't.
Adventures in the Marvelous Zone! A Girl's View of the Marvel Universe
I can promise you that they won't improve, if we don't.
Adventures in the Marvelous Zone! A Girl's View of the Marvel Universe
-
- Minion
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sun Nov 02, 2008 8:24 am
Re: Official Index to the Marvel Universe #7
I have all of these books.
-
- Minion
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sun Nov 02, 2008 8:24 am
Re: Official Index to the Marvel Universe #7
Correction:
The chronology for Professor X has Hell’s Angel #1-4 occurring before Marvel Comics Presents #117-122, but the chronology for Wolverine has Hell’s Angel #1-5 occurring after Marvel Comics Presents #117-122.
Professor X (Current Chronology)
HA 1
HA 2
HA 3-BTS
HA 4
UX 291
UX 292
UX 293
MCP 117
MCP 118
MCP 119
MCP 120-BTS
MCP 121-BTS
MCP 122-BTS
It can probably go either way, so why not just move Hell’s Angel down in Professor X’s chronology:
Professor X (Suggested Updated Chronology)
UX 291
UX 292
UX 293
MCP 117
MCP 118
MCP 119
MCP 120-BTS
MCP 121-BTS
MCP 122-BTS
HA 1
HA 2
HA 3-BTS
HA 4
The chronology for Professor X has Hell’s Angel #1-4 occurring before Marvel Comics Presents #117-122, but the chronology for Wolverine has Hell’s Angel #1-5 occurring after Marvel Comics Presents #117-122.
Professor X (Current Chronology)
HA 1
HA 2
HA 3-BTS
HA 4
UX 291
UX 292
UX 293
MCP 117
MCP 118
MCP 119
MCP 120-BTS
MCP 121-BTS
MCP 122-BTS
It can probably go either way, so why not just move Hell’s Angel down in Professor X’s chronology:
Professor X (Suggested Updated Chronology)
UX 291
UX 292
UX 293
MCP 117
MCP 118
MCP 119
MCP 120-BTS
MCP 121-BTS
MCP 122-BTS
HA 1
HA 2
HA 3-BTS
HA 4