NM 14+ MGK 3 + MGK 4

Discuss chronologies for characters in the main "Marvel Universe"

Moderators: Paul Bourcier, Kevin W., Col_Fury, Arthur, JephYork, Somebody

Locked
Frans
Big Bad
Big Bad
Posts: 208
Joined: Tue May 01, 2012 1:18 pm
Location: Amsterdam, Netherlands

NM 14+ MGK 3 + MGK 4

Post by Frans » Sat Dec 21, 2013 1:44 pm

In New Mutants 14 Magik uses a teleportation disk to transport the other New Mutants and Stevie Hunter through Limbo (her past) to the living room of the mansion where S'ym attacks her. This same scene is also printed in Magik 3. It's exactly the same scene in both comics, apart from art. It's even the same wording. The only real difference is the panel before the "duo-panel". It shows the car where the New Mutants are in thrashing Illyana's bed, leaving her somewhat dazed. Not 100% positive but does the MCP use a ~ for same panels in different comics? Or does MCP look at publishing date and mentions the oldest comic?

Magik 4 seems to have a new scene though, please find explanation below.

Basically the Magik limited series is nearly one big flashback to Illyana's time in Limbo. Magik 1 starts with her looking at her blood stones amulet, just before NM 14 starts. The scenes in MGK 1/MGK 4 and NM 14 have a lot of overlap. I'm not sure how MCP deals with panels that are the same or nearly the same.

MGK 1, page 1 shows Illyana on top of a hill at the X-Mansion. She opens her blood amulet. The weather is fine.
NM 14, pages 1- 4:3. It start with an open blood amulet. Illyana becomes angry thinking of her past. She walks away. She realises it snows. Wolfsbane, Psyche, Sunspot, Magma and Cannonball leave the Mansion to have fun in the snow. Mirage wishes a palm tree for Magma to cheer her up.
MGK 4 pages 22-23. Illyana is on top of the hill. She realises it snows (same panels as in NM 14). She strolls downwards the hill. While walking towards the Mansion she sees the New Mutants playing. Last scene is nearby the Mansion.
NM 14 pages 4:4 -22 Illyana looks at the New Mutants playing together. Professor X observes. The New Mutants at their turn see Professor X looking grim at Illyana. And then the rest of the issue including MGK 3 "flashback".

Below is my attempt...

RASPUTINA, ILLYANA
...
UX 160 (1 - 20)
* MGK 1-FB (2-23) added page numbers
MGK 2
MGK 3
* MGK 4-FB (1-22:3) added page numbers
UX 160 (21 - 22)
...

MAGIK/ILLYANA RASPUTINA
* MGK 1 (1) added
* NM 14 (1-4:3) added page numbers
* MGK 4 (22:4-23) added
* NM 14 (4:4-22) added
NM 15
...

PSYCHE/DANIELLE MOONSTAR
...
X&M 4
* NM 14 (1-4:3) added page numbers
* MGK 4 (23) added
* NM 14 (4:4-11:2) added
* NM 14 (11:3) ~ MGK 3 (12:3) added same sequence
* NM 14 (11:4-22) added
NM 15
...

WOLFSBANE/RAHNE SINCLAIR
...
X&M 4
* NM 14 (1-4:3) added page numbers
* MGK 4 (23) added
* NM 14 (4:4-11:2) added
* NM 14 (11:3) ~ MGK 3 (12:3) added same sequence
* NM 14 (11:4-22) added
NM 15
...

CANNONBALL/SAMUEL ZACHARY GUTHRIE
...
X&M 4
* NM 14 (1-4:3) added page numbers
* MGK 4 (23) added
* NM 14 (4:4-11:2) added
* NM 14 (11:3) ~ MGK 3 (12:3) added same sequence
* NM 14 (11:4-22) added
NM 15
...

SUNSPOT/ROBERTO DACOSTA
...
X&M 4
* NM 14 (1-4:3) added page numbers
* MGK 4 (23) added
* NM 14 (4:4-11:2) added
* NM 14 (11:3) ~ MGK 3 (12:3) added same sequence
* NM 14 (11:4-22) added
NM 15
...

MAGMA/AMARA AQUILLA/ALLISON CRESTMERE
...
X&M 4
* NM 14 (1-4:3) added page numbers
* MGK 4 (23) added
* NM 14 (4:4-11:2) added
* NM 14 (11:3) ~ MGK 3 (12:3) added same sequence
* NM 14 (11:4-22) added
NM 15
...

HUNTER, STEVIE
...
NM 13
* NM 14 (1-11:2) added
* NM 14 (11:3) ~ MGK 3 (12:3) added same sequence
* NM 14 (11:4-22) added
NM@ 1
...

Locked