X-Statix 1-FB

Discuss chronologies for characters in the main "Marvel Universe"

Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb

Locked
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1443
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

X-Statix 1-FB

Post by Leoparis »

This flashback intersects with X-Force 116 and there is a second flashback for U-Go Girl

page 1 video of their final battle, featuring U-Go Girl, Anarchist, Zeitgeist
page 2 video faturing Battering Ram & La Nuit

ANARCHIST/TIKE ALICAR
XFOR 116 (1-16)
XSTATIX 1-FB (1)
XFOR 116 (17-20:2)

BATTERING RAM
XFOR 116 (1-16)
XSTATIX 1-FB (2)
XFOR 116 (17-20:2)

LA NUIT
XFOR 116} (1-16)
XSTATIX 1-FB (2)
XFOR 116 (17-22)

U-GO GIRL/EDIE SAWYER
XFOR 116 (1-16)
XSTATIX 1-FB (1)
XFOR 116 (17-22)

ZEITGEIST II/AXEL CLUNEY
XFOR 116 (1-11)
XFOR 120-FB
XFOR 116 (12-16)
XSTATIX 1-FB (1)
XFOR 116 (17-20:2)

To handle the fb, I had to review Edie's early chronology.
The current one, here, doesn't make sense:

U-GO GIRL/EDIE SAWYER
XFOR 124-FB (as a girl, at 15 years old getting pregnant and having a baby nine months later)
XSTATIX 1-FB-BTS (20:2) a phone recorded message sent to a boy while he was in a coma after a beating. There's no indication when it takes place but presumably after she got famous as an X-Force member on page 21 of X-Statix 10-FB)
XFOR 121-FB-FB (fighting vs armed men as U-Go Girl--no indication when that takes place.)
XSTATIX 10-FB (this occurs right after XFOR 124-FB and shows how she joined X-Force and got famous. Covers her life from 16 to 20)
{XFOR 116-FB}

The fb-fb in XFOR 121 was very hard to find due once again to inconsistent treatment of the footage sections as flashbacks. In particular, while there was a FB-FB indicated there was no FB where to place it (http://www.chronologygraph.com/searchth ... FB-FB12914).

9:1 U-Go Girl fighting vs armed men as the picture is commented by a voiceover.
The voiceover indicates it's footage we're seeing

9:2 depicts Edie Sawyer in a TV show with a screen behind her showing the fight continuing.
We have two pictures within a picture. The screen shot takes place after the previous panel--the fight continues--while the panel occurs at some later time during the TV show.
To distinguish them, I'll refer to them as 9:2 panel and 9:2 screen shot.

9:3 Guy Smith and Edie at home watching her show. The screen depicts the previous panel (9:2).
This is because of this latest panel that 9:2 panel is interpreted as a flashback and 9:1 and 9:2 panel as a flashback within a flashback. But if 9:2 is a flashback, it's missing from the chronology (http://www.chronologygraph.com/searchth ... FB-FB12914).

What's more there's no reason to interpret 9:1 & 9:2 screen shot as a FB-FB and 9:2 panel as a FB. We don't have to assume Guy and Edie are off-panel watching the TV show in these first two panels. The narrative can simply switch from page 8 to the TV show and then to Guy and Edie watching the TV show.

BTW 10:2 also includes a screen shot of Edie in a TV commercial, continuing from the TV show. However it was likely filmed at a different time than the live show.

U-GO GIRL/EDIE SAWYER

XFOR 124-FB (at 15 years old getting pregnant and having a baby, teleports to Hollywood)
XSTATIX 10-FB (this occurs right after XFOR 124-FB and shows how she joined X-Force and got famous)
XFOR 121-FB (9:1-2) (fighting vs armed men as U-Go Girl.)
XSTATIX 1-FB-VO (20:2) (a phone recorded message sent to a boy while he was in a coma after a beating.)
{XFOR 116-FB}
XFOR 116 (1 - 16)
XSTATIX 1 (1)-FB
XFOR 116 (17 - 22)
XFOR 117-FB
XFOR 117
Locked