Concerning the new Official Index
Posted: Sat May 08, 2010 12:20 am
First of all, while I'm glad to see this series is back, who exactly chose its new name? I mean, AVENGERS; THOR & CAPTAIN AMERICA: OFFICIAL INDEX TO THE MARVEL UNIVERSE is a long and unwieldy title. Also, wouldn't having the "Official Index" part come before the "Avengers, Thor & Captain America" part make more sense? That way, any alphabetical listing of Marvel titles would have all Official Indexes listed together.
Second, is this meant to be a miniseries or an ongoing series? If it is a miniseries, then shouldn't it have a "Marvel Limited Series/1 of X" notation on the cover? And if it's an ongoing series, does that mean that once the Avengers/Thor/Captain America synopses are finished, then its name will change while the numbering continues on?
Third, I haven't had a chance to look through it all yet but there was one thing that I noticed right away. The sidebar dealing with the "Death" of Captain America and Bucky actually mentioned that Dekker/Newfoundland storyline from CA #218-220. I started collecting Cap in the late 220's and some of the first Cap back issues that I ever bought covered that storyline. It was one of the first retcons that I ever encountered and I rather liked it. Unlike far too many more-recent retcons, this one seemed to be well-done and it actually served a purpose. Unfortunately, every retelling of Cap's story (with one exception) has chosen to omit the events depicted in that storyline so it was refreshing to see them at least referenced here. Of course, I doubt that I'll ever see that Newfoundland adventure ever included in any future retellings of Cap's life.
I look forward to reading future issues.
Don Campbell
Second, is this meant to be a miniseries or an ongoing series? If it is a miniseries, then shouldn't it have a "Marvel Limited Series/1 of X" notation on the cover? And if it's an ongoing series, does that mean that once the Avengers/Thor/Captain America synopses are finished, then its name will change while the numbering continues on?
Third, I haven't had a chance to look through it all yet but there was one thing that I noticed right away. The sidebar dealing with the "Death" of Captain America and Bucky actually mentioned that Dekker/Newfoundland storyline from CA #218-220. I started collecting Cap in the late 220's and some of the first Cap back issues that I ever bought covered that storyline. It was one of the first retcons that I ever encountered and I rather liked it. Unlike far too many more-recent retcons, this one seemed to be well-done and it actually served a purpose. Unfortunately, every retelling of Cap's story (with one exception) has chosen to omit the events depicted in that storyline so it was refreshing to see them at least referenced here. Of course, I doubt that I'll ever see that Newfoundland adventure ever included in any future retellings of Cap's life.
I look forward to reading future issues.
Don Campbell