What If…? v2

Here's where you report issue analyses of any issue in any universe or timeline.

Moderators: Paul Bourcier, Kevin W., Col_Fury, Arthur, JephYork, Somebody

Locked
User avatar
Col_Fury
Director
Director
Posts: 6315
Joined: Sun Jun 26, 2005 3:37 am
Location: Illinois
Contact:

What If…? v2

Post by Col_Fury » Tue Oct 28, 2014 11:26 pm

Again, I’m mainly just looking for Watcher appearances. He doesn’t appear in all of these, so I’ll point out if he appears or not. Some Marvel Universe characters appear as well (like in W?2 60, the Scott/Jean wedding issue), but for the most part those are already in the MCP. If they’re already listed I won’t bother mentioning them. Also, some of these are already in the Watcher’s chronology.

WHAT IF…? v2 #1 (July, 1989)
What if the Avengers had lost the Evolutionary War?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #2 (August, 1989)
What if Daredevil had killed the Kingpin?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #3 (September, 1989)
What if Steve Rogers had refused to give up being Captain America?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #4 (October, 1989)
What if the alien costume had possessed Spider-Man?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #5 (November, 1989)
What if Wonder Man had not died? & What if the Vision had destroyed the Avengers?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #6 (November, 1989)
What if the X-Men had lost Inferno?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #7 (December, 1989)
Wolverine, Agent of SHIELD
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #8 (December, 1989)
What if Iron Man lost the Armor Wars?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #9 (January, 1990)
What if the new X-Men had died on their very first mission?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #10 (February, 1990)
What if the Punisher's family had not been killed in Central Park?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #11 (March, 1990)
What if the Fantastic Four all had the same power as…?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #12 (April, 1990)
What if the X-Men had stayed in Asgard?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #13 (May, 1990)
What if Professor X had become the Juggernaut?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #14 (June, 1990)
What if Captain Marvel had not died?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #15 (July, 1990)
What if the trial of Galactus had ended in Reed Richard's execution?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #16 (August, 1990)
What if Wolverine had lived during the age of Conan the Barbarian?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #17 (September, 1990)
What if Kraven the Hunter had killed Spider-Man?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #18 (October, 1990)
What if the Fantastic Four battled Dr. Doom before they gained their powers?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #19 (November, 1990)
What if the Vision had conquered the world?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #20 (December, 1990)
What if Spider-Man had not married Mary Jane Watson?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #21 (January, 1991)
What if Spider-Man married the Black Cat?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #22 (February, 1991)
What if the Silver Surfer had not escaped Earth?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #23 (March, 1991)
What if the All-New All-Different X-Men had never existed?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #24 (April, 1991)
What if Wolverine had become the lord of vampires?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #25 (May, 1991)
What if Set had come to Earth?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #26 (June, 1991)
What if the Punisher killed Daredevil?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #27 (July, 1991)
What if the Sub-Mariner had joined the Fantastic Four?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #28 (August, 1991)
What if Captain America were not the only super soldier in World War II?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #29 (September, 1991)
What if Captain America had formed the Avengers?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #30 (October, 1991)
What if the Invisible Woman had her second child?
Yes

2nd story:
What if the Fantastic Four's second child had lived?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #31 (November, 1991)
What if Spider-Man had not lost his cosmic powers?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #32 (December, 1991)
What if Phoenix had lived?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #33 (January, 1992)
What if Phoenix rose again?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #34 (February, 1992)
It’s the comedy issue! Again! The Watcher does appear in the first strip.

WHAT IF…? v2 #35 (March, 1992)
What if the Fantastic Five had invaded the Negative Zone? Timequake Part 1 of 5
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #36 (April, 1992)
What if the Cosmic Avengers and the Guardians of the Galaxy had been defeated by Korvac? Timequake Part 2 of 5
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #37 (May, 1992)
What if Wolverine and his X-Vampires conquered the world? Timequake Part 3 of 5
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #38 (June, 1992)
What if Thor had become a thrall of Seth? Timequake Part 4 of 5
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #39 (July, 1992)
What if the Watcher saved the Multiverse? Timequake Part 5 of 5
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #40 (August, 1992)
What if Storm stayed a thief?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #41 (September, 1992)
What if the Avengers had fought Galactus?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #42 (October, 1992)
What if Spider-Man never lost his four extra arms?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #43 (November, 1992)
What if Wolverine had married Mariko?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #44 (December, 1992)
What if Venom had possessed the Punisher?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #45 (January, 1993)
What if Barbara Ketch became Ghost Rider?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #46 (February, 1993)
What if Cable had destroyed the X-Men? Part 1 of 2
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #47 (March, 1993)
What if Magneto took over the United States? Part 2 of 2
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #48 (April, 1993)
What if Daredevil saved Nuke?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #49 (May, 1993)
What if the Silver Surfer possessed the Infinity Gauntlet?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #50 (June, 1993)
What if the Hulk killed Wolverine?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #51 (July, 1993)
What if the Punisher had become Captain America?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #52 (August, 1993)
What if Dr. Doom became Sorcerer Supreme?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #53 (September, 1993)
What if the Iron Man of 2020 had been stranded in the past?
Yes

2nd story:
What if Rick Jones remained the Hulk?
Yes

2nd story:
What if Spider-Man killed the Lizard?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #54 (October, 1993)
What if Minion had not killed Death's Head?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #55 (November, 1993)
What If the Avengers lost Operation: Galactic Storm? Part 1 of 2
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #56 (December, 1993)
What If the Avengers lost Operation: Galactic Storm? Part 2of 2
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #57 (January, 1994)
Hall of the dead
No (for the first time! Blame Chuck Dixon; he wrote it)

WHAT IF…? v2 #58 (February, 1994)
The day I killed Spider-Man
No (Dixon again!)

WHAT IF…? v2 #59 (March, 1994)
What if Wolverine had remained a captive of Alpha Flight?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #60 (April, 1994)
What if Scott Summers and Jean Grey had married earlier? &
What if Scott Summers and Jean Grey had never fallen in love at all? &
What if Phoenix had fallen for Wolverine?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #61 (May, 1994)
What if Spider-Man's "parents" destroyed his family?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #62 (June, 1994)
What if Logan battled Weapon X?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #63 (July, 1994)
What if War Machine had not destroyed the Living Laser?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #64 (August, 1994)
What if Iron Man went public?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #65 (September, 1994)
--A fallen Angel!
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #66 (October, 1994)
What if Rogue possessed the power of Thor?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #67 (November, 1994)
What If Captain America Were Revived Today? Part I: A fighting chance
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #68 (December, 1994)
What If Captain America Were Revived Today? Part II: Liberty's sword
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #69 (January, 1995)
What if Stryfe and Apocalypse killed the X-Men?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #70 (February, 1995)
The end of the matter: What if Silver Surfer had not betrayed Galactus?
No, but an alternate reality Watcher does.

WHAT IF…? v2 #71 (March, 1995)
What if the gamma bomb spawned a thousand Hulks?
Yes

WHAT IF…? v2 #72 (April, 1995)
What if Spider-Man became a murderer?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #73 (May, 1995)
What if the Kingpin "adopted" Daredevil?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #74 (June, 1995)
What if Mister Sinister formed the X-Men?: Sinister perspectives
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #75 (July, 1995)
What if Blink had killed Generation X?: Variations on a scream
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #76 (August, 1995)
What if Peter Parker had to invent Spider-Man?
Yes (the cover says this is the last issue to feature the Watcher, but I’ll keep looking anyway. The Watcher did get fired from his job a few months earlier in FF 400, so it does make sense, I guess… Not that it lasted long; he was back a year later for the Onslaught crossover without an explanation)

WHAT IF…? v2 #77 (September, 1995)
One dream: What if Legion had killed Magneto?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #78 (October, 1995)
4 against the darkness!
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #79 (November, 1995)
Covenants broken
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #80 (December, 1995)
What if the Hulk got himself cured?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #81 (January, 1996)
United we stand: What if the Age of Apocalypse had not ended?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #82 (February, 1996)
The man in the million dollar mask: What if J. Jonah Jameson adopted Peter Parker?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #83 (March, 1996)
The disciple's Devil! What if Daredevil was the disciple of Doctor Strange?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #84 (April, 1996)
To the finish! What if Shard journeyed to the present in Bishop’s place?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #85 (May, 1996)
Genesis revoked What of Magneto ruled all mutants?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #86 (June, 1996)
The answer to the question -- What if the Scarlet Spider had killed Spider-Man?
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #87 (July, 1996)
Cat and mouse
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #88 (August, 1996)
Arachnamorphosis
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #89 (September, 1996)
The fantastic farce
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #90 (October, 1996)
In the shadows
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #91 (November, 1996)
The man the monster
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #92 (December, 1996)
…I'll be your best friend!

WHAT IF…? v2 #93 (January, 1997)
Ferus
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #94 (February, 1997)
Wanderings
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #95 (March, 1997)
Broken soul
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #96 (April, 1997)
They grow up so quickly
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #97 (May, 1997)
Last light
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #98 (June, 1997)
Seeds of yesterday
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #-1 (July, 1997)
The traitor
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #99 (August, 1997)
Mask of the innocent
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #100 (September, 1997)
Paper skin
No

2nd story:
There's no place like that place where you sleep and keep all your stuff
No, but an alternate reality guy called Youaretoo the Looker appears.

WHAT IF…? v2 #101 (October, 1997)
Angel of Death
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #102 (November, 1997)
Shadow boxing
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #103 (December, 1997)
Prodigal son
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #104 (January, 1998)
Finders keepers
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #105 (February, 1998)
Legacy... in black and white
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #106 (March, 1998)
Retribution!
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #107 (April, 1998)
If this age be golden--!
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #108 (May, 1998)
The greatest sacrifice!
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #109 (June, 1998)
Tragedy in a tiny town
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #110 (July, 1998)
Family tie
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #111 (August, 1998)
Comes the Horseman--!
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #112 (September, 1998)
Brave old world
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #113 (October, 1998)
Anthony Stark, master of the mystic arts!
No

WHAT IF…? v2 #114 (November, 1998)
Brave new world
Nope. I guess they were serious.

Placement suggestions:

LIVING LASER/ARTHUR PARKS

IM 211
Q 6
**WI?2 9-BTS (delete)
*WI?2 9
Q 30-FB


STORM/ORORO MUNROE

X 78-FB
**WI?2 79 (9 - 10)-FB (delete)
*WI?2 79-FB
X:HY 7-FB


THUNDERBIRD II/JAMES PROUDSTAR
XFOR -1-FB
XFOR -1
**WI?2 9-FB (delete)
CX 3/2


UATU [WATCHER]

M/CP 17/3
*WI?2 1
*WI?2 2
*WI?2 3
*WI?2 4
*WI?2 5
*WI?2 6
*WI?2 8 (move from here)
**Q 6 (12) (delete)
**WI?2 9 (1 - 10) (delete)
**Q 6 (15 - 16) (delete)
**WI?2 9 (28) (delete)
SS@ 2/5
IM@ 10/4
UX@ 13/3
ASM@ 23/4
PUN@ 2/4
PPTSS@ 9/5
DD@ 5/5
A@ 18/4
NM@ 5/3
XF@ 4/4
WOSM@ 5/5
AWC@ 4/5
T@ 14/5
FF@ 22/5
*WI?2 7
*WI?2 8 (move to here)
*Q 6 (1 - 12)
*WI?2 9 (1 - 8)
*Q 6 (13 - 22)
*WI?2 9 (9 - 26)
*WI?2 10
*WI?2 11
*WI?2 12
*WI?2 13
*WI?2 14
*WI?2 15
XCAL 25
*WI? 16
*WI?2 17
*WI?2 18
*WI?2 19
NW 6
*WI?2 20
*WI?2 21
*WI?2 22
*WI?2 23
*WI?2 24
*WI?2 25
*WI?2 26
XF 68
DAMCON3 4
A@ 20/2
A 334
A 337
A 338
A 339
WI?2 27
Q 25
WI?2 28
WI?2 29
WI?2 30
WI?2 30/2
*WI?2 31 (move from here)
IG 3
IG 4 (1 - 3)
DRSTR3 33-BTS
IG 4 (4 - 40)
IG 5
IG 6-BTS
*WIW 1 (move to here)
IMSVS 2
*WI?2 31 (move to here)
*WI?2 32
Q 30
Q 31
*WI?2 33
A 344
*WI?2 34
SLAP 1
*WIW 1 (move from here)
*WI?2 35
*WI?2 36
*WI?2 37
*WI?2 38
*WI?2 39
FF 369
IW 4
IW 5
IW 6
WI?2 40
WI?2 41
WI?2 42
WI?2 43
WI?2 44
WI?2 45
FF 371
FF 373
FF 374
FF 375
A 357
WI?2 46
WI?2 47
WI?2 49
WI?2 50
*Q 47 (move from here)
A 363
*WI?2 51
*WI?2 52
*Q 47 (move to here)
*WI?2 53 (move to here)
*WI?2 53/2 (move to here)
*WI?2 53/3 (move to here)
IC 2
IC 3
DLOK2 29/2
STARBLAST 1
Q 54
STARBLAST 3
Q 56
STARBLAST 4
Q 57
*WI?2 53 (move from here)
*WI?2 53/2 (move from here)
*WI?2 53/3 (move from here)
*WI?2 54
*WI?2 55
*WI?2 56
*WI?2 59
FF 387
WI?2 60
WI?2 61
*WI?2 62
*WI?2 63
*WI?2 64
*WI?2 65
*WI?2 69
X 40
*WI?2 71
*WI?2 76 (move to here)
FF 397
FFOR 7
FF 400
*WI?2 76 (move from here)
UX 335
-Daron Jensen

Midnighter
Hero
Hero
Posts: 88
Joined: Sat May 08, 2010 7:47 am

Re: What If…? v2

Post by Midnighter » Wed Oct 29, 2014 3:34 am

Didn't you catch the "crossover" between What If...? 9 and Quasar 6?
http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.co ... ealed-323/ (the second "legend" on that page).
The Living Laser (616) actually appears in WI?2 9!

User avatar
Col_Fury
Director
Director
Posts: 6315
Joined: Sun Jun 26, 2005 3:37 am
Location: Illinois
Contact:

Re: What If…? v2

Post by Col_Fury » Wed Oct 29, 2014 4:40 am

Neat, isn't it? :)

That bit is already in the MCP listings (so I didn't feel the need to mention it), but Living Laser is currently only given a BTS for WI?2 9. But I agree with you that Living Laser is actually on panel in WI?2 9 (the beam that blows up Nefaria's craft), so I suggested changing WI?2 9 to a full appearance in Living Laser's chronology (instead of the -BTS it currently is).

Thanks, Midnighter!
-Daron Jensen

Locked