Marvel Chronology Project

This is actually the same character as the coach Sam Thorne who is already listed in the same issue. The issue simply misspelled his name, and there can be no doubt that this is the same person. The following listing should be deleted.

THORPE, COACH
FF 51

KING ARRKAM
TTA 75/2
TTA 76/2
TTA 77/2 <-- ADD

King Arrkam appears on first two panels of page 10 in TTA 77/2. One of his subjects calls him Sire so his identity as King Arrkam makes no doubt.

But my suggestion was just that, a suggestion. My post did not imply in any way the MCP had made a mistake in not including her. As the answers from Russ and Col Fury show, the MCP does not have an automatic inclusion policy nor do we extend the practice for celebrities to other characters. Suggest...

I don't know what's the MCP view. She makes a guest appearance with a speaking part and so I thought she deserved inclusion. ... My point in this query was mainly that she appears once in a single panel. So using that same logic, does that mean we should start listing people who have a full name an...

Although she is not identified by name in the comic or in any index, it is clear that she is the one the artist intended to draw here. That being said, i don't know how MCP proceeds with this kind of cameo, but since she adds very little to the plot and only appears in a single panel in a single iss...

Engagement of Reed and Sue to Defeat of Galactus: ... Tales of Suspense 74-75 Tales of Suspense 76 (1 - 12:3) Avengers Spotlight 22/2 [History of the Swordsman] Avengers 48 (12:1 - 12:2)-FB Marvels 3 (5) Amazing Spider-Man 657 (3 - 10)-FB Amazing Spider-Man 29-33 [Peter begins classes at ESU][ Sept...

Post has been moved here.

The listings are indeed inconsistent and have to be corrected. Here is my take on your remarks, but I'm only human and can make mistakes, so I can be corrected by other directors. It's true that for early 60es comics, the first page is often a generic splash page and we don't consider it. But A 4 (...

Never thought this character would be listed in MCP, but since it is, let's fix a little error in the story number:

TRINKET
COMEDYC 9/8 --> CHANGE TO COMEDYC 9/7 (9/8 is the Fin story)
HTC 10/2

According to Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe A-Z Update Vol 1 1, the name for this character should read like this: FEEPERS --> CHANGE TO FEEPERS, WEYLIN DD 13 DD 14 Also, unless characters whose name are not complete do not qualify for listing, this character should also be added because h...

Minor change needs to be done in the name since it is the way he is called in the whole story:

RIBBENDORF, ADMIRAL --> CHANGE TO RIBBONDORF, VICE-ADMIRAL
SGTF 26

This character is significant enough to be added:

SLAGG/JOHN HENLEY
DD 12
DD 13

Minor adjustment required

HURLEY, DAN
DARMC 7/5
DARMC 8/5 --> REPLACE with DARMC 8/5-BTS (does not appear, but someone visits his office to get help)
COMEDYC 9/5
INV2 2 <-- ADD

Some real-life celebrities who appear in more than one comic may deserve be listed. Here are a few I can think of:

CROSBY, BING
SGTF 24
FF 9

HOPE, BOB
SGTF 24
SGTF 43
FF 9

MILLER, GLENN
SGTF 24
SGTF 43

There seems to be a few discrepancies in your listings for characters who appear in FF@3, mostly regarding Thor. This is probably due to the discrepancies in the Official Index for Thor and the one for the Avengers. The story in A 22 establishes that it occurs during TOS 72 which is also confirmed b...