I think you meant BP4 26 here.Paul Bourcier wrote:I believe time does pass between Cap's surrender and his murder, during which he's incarcerated. Thus the gap between 5:2 and 5:3. And I believe BP3 26 (7-8) and BLADE8 9 occur during that period, as well as CW:FL 11 (6-12).
Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb
-
- Chronology Guru
- Posts: 644
- Joined: Sat Feb 21, 2004 2:54 am
- Location: Holland, Massachusetts
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
-
- Comic Pro
- Posts: 5424
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 6:51 am
- Location: Florida
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Sean C. wrote:
Indeed. Thanks.I think you meant BP4 26 here.
Paul B.
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
I understand that.Paul Bourcier wrote:Ork wrote:Check out my entry for Annihilation: Prologue on October 23 of Year 23:I found some problems with the "Annihilation days".
For example, October 30 is Annihilation Day+11 and +12, and November 13 is AD+40 and +41. Is it on purpose?
"Because NOVA4 1 occurs roughly 'six months' after this segment, all those references cannot be Earth days, but rather "Annihilation days" that I estimate are half as long as Earth days."
Does this change any of the corrections you suggested?
But if October 30 is AD+11 and AD+12, November 13 should be AD+39 and AD+40 (28 Annihilation days later are 14 Earth days, not 14.5).
ANNIHILATION: SUPER-SKRULL #1 (1-10) is AD+41. It should be on November 14.
If ANNIHILATION #2 - FB is AD+183, it should be on January 24, not 23.
ANNIHILATION: HERALDS OF GALACTUS #1 (12-22) is AD+223, it should be February 13, not 12.
ANNIHILATION #6 (25-26) is AD+277, it should be March 11, not 10.
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
I have the French ones. If someone with the original version could verify, it'd be better.Paul Bourcier wrote:I don't have the Annihilation comics, so can't see how I messed up page counts. I may have misinterpreted a posted analysis. If you're sure on those page counts, I can change 'em. Thanks!
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
No problem to have the surrender and the murder one month apart. But CAPTAIN AMERICA v5 #25 (4-5:2) is only a TV news reporter recounting the events, not the events themselves.Paul Bourcier wrote:Ork wrote:Thanks for noticing the lack of ":3." I believe time does pass between Cap's surrender and his murder, during which he's incarcerated. Thus the gap between 5:2 and 5:3. And I believe BP3 26 (7-8) and BLADE8 9 occur during that period, as well as CW:FL 11 (6-12).I suppose you meant to start at 5:3. I cannot see one month between panels 2 and 3. I would have made only one entry:
March 13
CAPTAIN AMERICA v5 #25 (4-15:4)
-
- Comic Pro
- Posts: 5424
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 6:51 am
- Location: Florida
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Ork wrote:
Ork wrote:
Yes, but the reporter's dialog makes little sense if it all occurred a month after Cap's surrender. "---if you're just tuning in, you heard correctly. Steve Rogers -- Captain America -- has surrended to authorities. The brutal conflict over the Superhuman Regustration Act is over....Though whether Rogers' arrest will bring peace or healing to the super hero community...or to this nation...is a question that only time can answer." This is clearly written as a breaking news story.No problem to have the surrender and the murder one month apart. But CAPTAIN AMERICA v5 #25 (4-5:2) is only a TV news reporter recounting the events, not the events themselves.
Ork wrote:
Ah, I see. Are these the only Annihilation entries that have problems?I understand that.
But if October 30 is AD+11 and AD+12, November 13 should be AD+39 and AD+40 (28 Annihilation days later are 14 Earth days, not 14.5).
ANNIHILATION: SUPER-SKRULL #1 (1-10) is AD+41. It should be on November 14.
If ANNIHILATION #2 - FB is AD+183, it should be on January 24, not 23.
ANNIHILATION: HERALDS OF GALACTUS #1 (12-22) is AD+223, it should be February 13, not 12.
ANNIHILATION #6 (25-26) is AD+277, it should be March 11, not 10.
Paul B.
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Per X-Factor v3 #6 & #9, this didn't happen. #6 establishes Layla's as an orphan who lived in an orphanage pre-M-Day; and she writes this scene off in #9 as:HOUSE OF M #8 (1-6:5)
The same morning as HOM:DA 1 (1-2) and GSMM 1. Layla Miller is woken by her mother on a school day.
Layla Miller, XF3 9 (16:4-16:5) wrote:"I don't have any 'folks'." [WOLVERINE: "What, but you said..."] "I lied. In the... 'other' world... I had parents. But not before. And not now. I had this nice dream of them, just before things changed back. My mom was calling me, telling me it was time for school. Then I woke up, back in the orphanage. Back in the world I hated."
-
- Comic Pro
- Posts: 5424
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 6:51 am
- Location: Florida
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Somebody wrote:
Thanks, Somebody. I'll edit that calendar entry.Per X-Factor v3 #6 & #9, this didn't happen. #6 establishes Layla's as an orphan who lived in an orphanage pre-M-Day
Paul B.
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
One of these volume numbers is wrong. It's the "v2" one - although "M/TU 23/2 (1-2)" also drops the 3.MARVEL TEAM-UP v3 #22 (7-8)
The same night as M/TU3 21. At the hospital, Curtis' friends are told that his prognosis is not good.
MARVEL TEAM-UP v2 #22 (14-15)
The same night as M/TU3 22 (7-8). This segment occurs "weeks" before M/TU 23/2 (1-2). Troy and Jeffrey stand beside the
bed of the comatose Curtis.
[Remind me, BTW, how did all the double-spacing happen again?]
-
- Comic Pro
- Posts: 5424
- Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2004 6:51 am
- Location: Florida
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Somebody wrote:
The problem occurs when I convert my original WordPerfect document into an HTML file. If anyone has pointers about how to maintain my single spacing in the conversion process, please let me know.Remind me, BTW, how did all the double-spacing happen again?
Paul B.
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Right.Paul Bourcier wrote:Ork wrote:Yes, but the reporter's dialog makes little sense if it all occurred a month after Cap's surrender. "---if you're just tuning in, you heard correctly. Steve Rogers -- Captain America -- has surrended to authorities. The brutal conflict over the Superhuman Regustration Act is over....Though whether Rogers' arrest will bring peace or healing to the super hero community...or to this nation...is a question that only time can answer." This is clearly written as a breaking news story.No problem to have the surrender and the murder one month apart. But CAPTAIN AMERICA v5 #25 (4-5:2) is only a TV news reporter recounting the events, not the events themselves.
I guess I've been mistaken by the French translation where the dialog in panel 3 seems to follow immediately the one in panel 2.
And by the fact that they put the same background behind the reporter.
And that she has the same clothes.
-
- Chronology Guru
- Posts: 1058
- Joined: Sun Jul 17, 2005 2:34 am
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
One way is to do your document writing in an html file originally.Paul Bourcier wrote:The problem occurs when I convert my original WordPerfect document into an HTML file. If anyone has pointers about how to maintain my single spacing in the conversion process, please let me know.
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
From the Annihilation Analysis Thread, I see that A:SIL has a recap page that is not in the French issue. That's why I counted only 23 pages.Paul Bourcier wrote:I don't have the Annihilation comics, so can't see how I messed up page counts. I may have misinterpreted a posted analysis. If you're sure on those page counts, I can change 'em. Thanks!
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Recap pages don't count (or, at least, shouldn't be counted) unless they have at least one original panel on them (like Ant-Man and the Ultimate books). The only Annihilation-related book that qualifies on that score off the top of my head is the Conquest Prologue.
Re: Marvel Calendar -- Latest Edition Now Online
Checked with both the comics I have and the Annihilation analysis thread.Paul Bourcier wrote:Ork wrote:Ah, I see. Are these the only Annihilation entries that have problems?I understand that.
But if October 30 is AD+11 and AD+12, November 13 should be AD+39 and AD+40 (28 Annihilation days later are 14 Earth days, not 14.5).
ANNIHILATION: SUPER-SKRULL #1 (1-10) is AD+41. It should be on November 14.
If ANNIHILATION #2 - FB is AD+183, it should be on January 24, not 23.
ANNIHILATION: HERALDS OF GALACTUS #1 (12-22) is AD+223, it should be February 13, not 12.
ANNIHILATION #6 (25-26) is AD+277, it should be March 11, not 10.
Add to these four, the A:SIL 3 on AD+20/21, not AD+21/22 (already indicated somewhere in this thread) and that's all I found.