THOR/THOR ODINSON/"DR. DONALD BLAKE"/"SIGURD JARLSON"/"JAKE OLSON"/"LOREN OLSON"
...
A 3 (22:3 - 25)
JIM 99
JIM 100
...
IRON MAN/ANTHONY EDWARD "TONY" STARK/"RICHARD FRANCO"
...
A 3 (13 - 25)
A 4 (2:1 - 2:4)
AC 3/2
...
GIANT-MAN/DR. HENRY JONATHAN PYM
...
A 3 (13 - 25)
A 4 (2:2 - 2:4)
AC 3/2
...
WASP/JANET VAN DYNE PYM
...
A 3 (13 - 25)
A 4 (1 - 3)-OP
TTA 51/3
...
SUB-MARINER/NAMOR MACKENZIE
...
A 3
A 4 (1 - 2:4)
SAGASUB 8 (14 - 16:4)-FB
...
You can clearly see that the listings are inconsistent for all characters. The Avengers appear only in A 4 (2:1). A 4 (2:2 - 2:4) only show Namor. I assume here that A 4 (1 - 2:4) was kept for Namor because that this what you call a scene and that it is ended by a panel in another book. The same rule should apply then to all of the Avengers, but it is not the case.
If you look back at my first post on this topic, my initial suggestion was to keep A 4 (2:1) only if it was not considered a retelling and remove A 4 (2:2 - 2:4) for the Avengers. I later learned that if it is considered a scene, their appearance should cover the whole scene even if they are not in those specific panels. I can live with that.
There are a couple of things to take into consideration here:
- Page one is a splash that has nothing to do with the story because it shows Thor welcoming Cap in the Avengers. It has no more weight here than a cover page and should be ignored in the listings (Subby's listing has kept it)
- A 4 (2:1) could be considered a retelling but was probably kept for some characters because it leads to the next 3 panels. This panel, sans the Wasp, summarizes A 3 (25:6), so to me, it's a retelling at best. I would remove it for all characters, period.
- On the other hand. If you consider that A 4 (2:1) shows a different point of view and that it is not a retelling, it should be marked as a flashback. We saw that scene. In addition, the narrative begins with "Remember the awesome battle between..." and the whole paragraphe is written in past tense.
- Then the narrative in A 4 (2:2) switches to present tense until the rest of the book. it picks up right where A 3 left off, with Namor going back to the sea.
- This means that the real story only begins at A 4 (2:2) and the actual scene should be A 4 (2:2 - 2:4). And since only Namor appears in it, it should be removed in the listings for all other characters.
Whether or not you agree with those points, I had to bring the matter up again so that, at least, the discrepancies between all characters are solved. What goes for Iron Man goes for Thor too.