Captain America and Bucky in Young Men 27/2 & Men's Adventures 28/2

Discuss chronologies for characters in the main "Marvel Universe"

Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb

Post Reply
User avatar
StrayLamb
Director
Director
Posts: 2302
Joined: Thu Jul 30, 2015 5:42 am
Location: a sheep paddock, along the Great Eastern Highway

Captain America and Bucky in Young Men 27/2 & Men's Adventures 28/2

Post by StrayLamb »

As zuckyd1 pointed out (http://www.chronologyproject.com/phpbb2 ... =2&t=14944), Cap & Bucky's appearance in Young Men 27/2, where they are already in the army, must occur after Captain America Comics 76/1, where they join the army. I don't see any way of fixing these appearances without contradicting the recent Captain America Index. The least disruption is to move only CAC 76/1

Also, their chronologies list their appearance in Men's Adventures 28/2 before Captain America Comics 77, but Cap and Bucky fly to South Korea in CAC 77/4 (job #E-335), and are still in Korea in MENADV 28/2 (job # E-374). Both the CA Index and the recent "Decades: Marvel in the '50's - Captain America Strikes" has the order CAC 77 --> MENADV 28 --> CAC 78. (It also incorrecly has YMEN 27 --> CAC 76 - oh well..)

Edit: i also propose that CAC 78/2 should precede CAC 78 and be placed immediately after MENADV 28/2, as Cap & Bucky are still in Korea in this episode. This is also backed up by the story's job number (#E-628), which follows MENADV 28/2 (#E-374) and precedes CAC 78 (#E-641) & CAC 78/4 (#E-642).


Suggested changes:

BUCKY III/JACK MONROE
---
YMEN 25/2
YMEN 26/2
CAC 76 [CAP & BUCKY JOIN ARMY] * MOVE TO HERE
YMEN 27/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN ARMY]
MENADV 27/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN ARMY]
CAC 76 [CAP & BUCKY JOIN ARMY] * MOVE FROM HERE
CAC 76/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN ARMY]
CAC 76/4 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN ARMY]
YMEN 28/2
MENADV 28/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN KOREA] * MOVE FROM HERE
CAC 77
CA5 38-FB
CAC 77/2
CAC 77/4 [CAP & BUCKY FLY TO KOREA]
MENADV 28/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN KOREA] * MOVE TO HERE
CAC 78/2 [CAP & BUCKY STILL IN KOREA] * MOVE TO HERE
CAC 78
CAC 78/2 [CAP & BUCKY STILL IN KOREA] * MOVE FROM HERE
CAC 78/4
---


CAPTAIN AMERICA IV/WILLIAM BURNSIDE/"STEVE ROGERS"
---
YMEN 25/2
YMEN 26/2
CAC 76 [CAP & BUCKY JOIN ARMY] * MOVE TO HERE
YMEN 27/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN ARMY]
MENADV 27/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN ARMY]
CAC 76 [CAP & BUCKY JOIN ARMY] * MOVE FROM HERE
CAC 76/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN ARMY]
CAC 76/4 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN ARMY]
YMEN 28/2
MENADV 28/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN KOREA] * MOVE FROM HERE
CAC 77
CA5 38-FB
CAC 77/2
CAC 77/4 [CAP & BUCKY FLY TO KOREA]
MENADV 28/2 [CAP & BUCKY ALREADY IN KOREA] * MOVE TO HERE
CAC 78/2 [CAP & BUCKY STILL IN KOREA] * MOVE TO HERE
CAC 78
CAC 78/2 [CAP & BUCKY STILL IN KOREA] * MOVE FROM HERE
CAC 78/4
---

(I hope i've got all my 27's and 28's right this time!)
Out in the Land Down-Under, beneath a rocky outcrop, deep within the back paddock, dwells the Stray Lamb.
User avatar
Col_Fury
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 7758
Joined: Sun Jun 26, 2005 3:37 am
Location: on a Helicarrier, above Illinois
Contact:

Re: Captain America and Bucky in Young Men 27/2 & Men's Adventures 28/2

Post by Col_Fury »

Just saw this. :)

I suggested moving both YMEN 27/2 & MENADV 27/2 to after CAC 76/4 based on publication order. We (and the Index) have it wrong as it is, so we might as well line up as much as we can. Also, all this Korea stuff makes sense to me. :yepp:

BUCKY III/JACK MONROE
……
YMEN 28/2
**MENADV 28/2 (move from here)
CAC 77
CA5 38-FB
CAC 77/2
CAC 77/4
*MENADV 28/2 (move to here)
*CAC 78/2 (move to here)
CAC 78
**CAC 78/2 (move from here)
CAC 78/4
……

CAPTAIN AMERICA IV/WILLIAM BURNSIDE/"STEVE ROGERS"
……
YMEN 28/2
**MENADV 28/2 (move from here)
CAC 77
CA5 38-FB
CAC 77/2
CAC 77/4
*MENADV 28/2 (move to here)
*CAC 78/2 (move to here)
CAC 78
**CAC 78/2 (move from here)
CAC 78/4
……
-Daron Jensen
Post Reply