Thor 370 & BP3 46-47

Here's where you report issue analyses of any issue in any universe or timeline.

Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb

Post Reply
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1443
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

Thor 370 & BP3 46-47

Post by Leoparis »

BP3 46-47 retells T 370 but it's indexed as if it occurs later. The two stories end differently, possibly due to the interference of the time-traveling characters in BP3 46-47.

I tried to construct a combined timeline:
T 370 (1 - 6) Sundance leaves Danville to deliver a message, Loki arrives
BP3 46 (1:1 - 1:3) Thor arrives
T 370 (7 - 8:1) = BP3 46 (1:4 - 1:5) finds dying old man
BP3 46 (2 - 15) BP & gang arrive, Everett arrested, freed by Sundance, future BP meets Loki
T 370 (8:2 - 11:1) Sundance meets Loki (9:5 - 10:7) retold in fb in BP3 47 (6:2-5)
T 370 (11:2 - 12:2) = BP3 46 (16) Sundance shoots at Thor
BP3 46 (17 - 18:3) BP & Monica, Everett recognizes Thor
T 370 (12:3-5) = BP3 46 (18:4) finds out he's the man
BP3 46 (18:5-7) BP & Monica face hoodlums
BP3 46 (19 - 22) Thor & Everett, Loki, BP & Monica meet Rawhide Kid, Kid Colt and Two-Gun Kid
T 370 (12:6 - 15) = BP3 47 (1 - 3:1) train attacked by Loki
BP3 47 (3:2) Thor, Sundance, Everett
T 370 (16:1-2) = BP3 47 (3:3-4) Loki eats apple
T 370 (16:3-5) Thor explains Idunn's apples to Sundance
BP3 47 (3:5 - 7:4) Thor, Sundance, Everett joined by BP, Rawhide Kid, Kid Colt and Two-Gun Kid
T 370 (16:6 - 17:2) They see Loki's train
T 370 (17:3) = BP3 47 (7:5) Thor grabs Mjölnir
T 370 (18:1) whirls it
T 370 (18:2) = BP3 47 (7:6) lightning
T 370 (18:3) = BP3 47 (8:1) turns into Thor on winged horse
T 370 (18:4 - 19:4) smashes train and attacks trolls
Beyond this point it is impossible to reconcile. I propose to read first T 370 to completion and then pick BP3 47 where it diverges. One of these has to be a divergent universe but which one? Probably T 370 is the original universe and BP3 46-47 is the 616 time travelers in the divergent universe. The Thor, Loki and Sundance of BP3 46-47 would be alternates and their appearances there should shift to alternate Earths (but do we have a number for it?).

Post Scriptum of Oct 25, 2023: I have now concluded that inquiry in the Alternate Universe/Timeline forum.

Suggested corrections (BP3 46-47 features an alternate timeline visited by 616 denizens):
KID COLT/BLAINE COLE/"BLAINE COLT"
FF3 34
BP3 46 delete and shift to alternate
BP3 47 delete and shift to alternate

LOKI
T 370
BP3 47-FB delete and shift to alternate
BP3 46 delete and shift to alternate
BP3 47 delete and shift to alternate

RAWHIDE KID II/JOHNNY CLAY/JOHNNY BART
[RK 33]
BP3 46 delete and shift to alternate
BP3 47 delete and shift to alternate

STEEL
A 143
BP3 46 delete and shift to alternate

SUNDANCE
{T 370} delete brackets
{BP3 46} delete and shift to alternate
BP3 47 delete and shift to alternate

THOR
T 370
BP3 46 delete and shift to alternate
BP3 47 delete and shift to alternate

TWO-GUN KID/MATTHEW J. LIEBOWICZ/"MATT HAWK"/"CLAY HARDER"
UACC 1
BP3 46 delete and shift to alternate
BP3 47 delete and shift to alternate


[[[CLICK & DRAG: This is abandoned as unworkable.
Suggested corrections (combining both versions):
LOKI
T 370 (1 - 8:1)
BP3 47-FB delete
BP3 46 (2 - 15)
T 370 (8:2 - 11:1)
BP3 46 (19 - 22)
T 370 (12:6 - 22)
BP3 47 (8:2 - 21)

SUNDANCE
BP3 47-FB delete
{T 370} (1 - 8:1) delete brackets, add range
{BP3 46} (2 - 15) delete brackets, add range
T 370 (8:2 - 12:5)
BP3 47 (3:2)
T 370 (16:3 - 16:5)
BP3 47 (3:5 - 7:4)
T 370 (16:6 - 22)
BP3 47 (8:2 - 21)

THOR
BP3 46 (1:1 - 1:3)
T 370 (11:2 - 12:2)
BP3 46 (17 - 18:3)
T 370 (12:3 - 12:5)
BP3 46 (19 - 22)
BP3 47 (3:2)
T 370 (16:3- 16:5)
BP3 47 (3:5 - 7:4)
T 370 (16:6 - 22)
BP3 47 (8:2 - 21)
]]]
Post Reply