Magneto Vol 4

Here's where you report issue analyses of any issue in any universe or timeline.

Moderators: Col_Fury, michel, Arthur, Somebody, StrayLamb

Post Reply
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1443
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

Magneto Vol 4

Post by Leoparis »

In the series a new villain called Irae tries to return Magneto to his villainous ways.

Per a note this is supposed to be circa NM 38. Indeed the students remember being wiped out by the Beyonder, NM 37, and there is snow on the grounds.
In NM 38 they were heavily traumatized and Magneto sent them to the Massachusetts Academy for treatment by Emma Frost. At the end on NM 40 they return to the Xavier school but Danielle had refused to follow to Massachusetts and had left home.
They look more lively in that mini than in NM 38-40. Roberto was out of the team between NM 37 & 43 and his presence is not explained. The nine students were not reunited before NM 44 and the spot after NM 44 may be a better one.

NM 38 has a day-to-day continuity and the only larger break is on page 16 between panels 4 & 5 "following weekend". So here is a NM 38 placement but if you think it best to postpone it to NM 44 to preserve the trauma and recovery sequence, make it known.

Suggested additions:
CANNONBALL/SAMUEL ZACHARY GUTHRIE
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)

CYPHER/DOUG RAMSEY
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)
NM 39

IRAE/ELENA PEREZ
M4 3-FB
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4

KARMA/XI'AN COY MANH
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)
NM 39

MAGIK/ILLYANA RASPUTINA
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)
NM 39

MAGMA/AMARA AQUILLA/ALLISON CRESTMERE
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)
NM 39

MAGNETO/MAGNUS/MAX EISENHARDT/"ERIC LENSHERR"/"MICHAEL XAVIER"
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)
NM 39

MIRAGE II/DANIELLE MOONSTAR
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)
NM 39

SUNSPOT/ROBERTO DA COSTA
NM 37
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 43

WARLOCK III [TECHNARCH]
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)
NM 39

WOLFSBANE/RAHNE SINCLAIR
SECWARSII 9
NM 38 (1 - 16:4)
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 38 (16:5 - 22)
NM 39
Jason Doty
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 9683
Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2004 6:24 pm
Location: Milton, Florida

Re: Magneto Vol 4

Post by Jason Doty »

I would go with NM 44, to preserve the recovery time and allow for Sunspot to have returned.
Leoparis
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 1443
Joined: Mon Jun 04, 2007 6:32 am
Location: Paris
Contact:

Re: Magneto Vol 4

Post by Leoparis »

I agree. After I posted, the NM 38 placement did not sit well with me and I already endeavored to modify it. The original continuity must trump the snow-covered grounds and the note.

StrayLamb argues for a placement after NM 52 as it fits the seasonal time. Indeed all characters are available in the spot he proposes.

Suggested placements:
CANNONBALL/SAMUEL ZACHARY GUTHRIE
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 51 (6:3 - 6:5)-FB
or
CANNONBALL/SAMUEL ZACHARY GUTHRIE
]]]NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
FANGELS 1

CYPHER/DOUG RAMSEY
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
NM 51 (6:3 - 6:5)-FB
or
CYPHER/DOUG RAMSEY
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
FANGELS 1

IRAE/ELENA PEREZ
M4 3-FB
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4

KARMA/XI'AN COY MANH
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 81-FB
or
KARMA/XI'AN COY MANH
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
FANGELS 1

MAGIK/ILLYANA RASPUTINA
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
WOSM@ 2
or
MAGIK/ILLYANA RASPUTINA
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
FANGELS 1

MAGMA/AMARA AQUILLA/ALLISON CRESTMERE
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
WOSM@ 2
or
MAGMA/AMARA AQUILLA/"ALLISON CRESTMERE"
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
FANGELS 1

MAGNETO/MAGNUS/MAX EISENHARDT/"ERIC LENSHERR"/"MICHAEL XAVIER"
WOSM2 2
X 4 (1 - 11)
M4 3-FB
X 4 (12 - 14:5)
X:L 209-FB
...
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 40
AF 33
VIS&SCRW2 12-FB
VIS&SCRW2 12
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
UX 210 (1 - 16:4)
or
MAGNETO/MAGNUS/MAX EISENHARDT/"ERIC LENSHERR"/"MICHAEL XAVIER"
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
FANGELS 1

MASTERMIND/JASON WYNGARDE
NA 9-FB
{X 4 (1 - 11)}
M4 3-FB
X 4 (12 - 14:5)
X:L 209-FB

MIRAGE II/DANIELLE MOONSTAR
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 51 (6:3 - 6:5)-FB
or
MIRAGE II/DANIELLE MOONSTAR
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
FANGELS 1

QUICKSILVER/PIETRO MAXIMOFF
WOSM2 2
{X 4 (1 - 11)}
M4 3-FB
X 4 (12 - 14:5)
X:L 209-FB

SCARLET WITCH II/WANDA MAXIMOFF
WOSM2 2
{X 4 (1 - 11)}
M4 3-FB
X 4 (12 - 14:5)
X:L 209-FB

TOAD II/MORTIMER TOYNBEE
XFVR 4
{X 4 (1 - 11)}
M4 3-FB
X 4 (12 - 14:5)
X:L 209-FB

SUNSPOT/ROBERTO DA COSTA
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 51 (6:3 - 6:5)-FB
or
SUNSPOT/ROBERTO DA COSTA
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
FANGELS 1

WARLOCK III [TECHNARCH]
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
WOSM@ 2
or
WARLOCK III [TECHNARCH]
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
FANGELS 1

WOLFSBANE/RAHNE SINCLAIR
[[[CLICK & DRAG: NM 44
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
NM 51 (6:3 - 6:5)-FB
or
WOLFSBANE/RAHNE SINCLAIR
]]]
NM 52
M4 1
M4 2
M4 3
M4 4
FANGELS 1
Jason Doty
Chronology Guru
Chronology Guru
Posts: 9683
Joined: Mon Mar 15, 2004 6:24 pm
Location: Milton, Florida

Re: Magneto Vol 4

Post by Jason Doty »

I think that could be a good spot.
Post Reply